Looking for Post-Traumatic Growth in Perpetrators of the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda: A Discussion of Theoretical and Ethical Issues

Laura E.R. Blackie, Nicki Hitchcott, Stephen Joseph

Abstract


The theory of post-traumatic growth claims that, in the struggle to overcome difficult experiences, individuals may identify positive ways in which the experience has changed them. There is extensive evidence of survivors of extreme adversities reporting the phenomenon across different cultures. Although reconciliation involves facilitating positive changes in the identities of perpetrators, post-traumatic growth has not yet been studied in relation to perpetrators of political violence. In this theoretical review article, we draw upon existing research to evaluate the applicability of the concept of post-traumatic growth in the context of perpetrators of the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda and discuss the unaddressed theoretical and ethical issues that need to be considered in this context. We conclude that it is feasible for post-traumatic growth to manifest in this population. However, we suggest that the current definition of this concept needs considerable revision including a focus on measuring behavioural change. We further conclude that researchers need to navigate this topic very carefully, given the ethical issues surrounding misrepresentation and inappropriate dissemination.

Keywords


Post-traumatic growth, perpetrators, violence, genocide, Rwanda

Full Text:

PDF

References


Arnold, Jobb, ‘A Psychological Investigation of Individual and Social Transformations in Post-Genocide Rwanda’, in Confronting Genocide, ed. by Rene Provost and Payam Akhavan (Springer Netherlands, 2011), pp. 305–17.

Clark, Phil, The Gacaca Courts, Post-Genocide Justice and Reconciliation in Rwanda (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010).

Clark, Phil, ‘Negotiating Reconciliation in Rwanda: Popular Challenges to the Official Discourse of Post-Genocide National Unity’, Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding, 8 (2014), 303–20.

Dekel, Sharon, Tsachi Ein-Dor, and Zahava Solomon, ‘Posttraumatic Growth and Posttraumatic Distress: A Longitudinal Study.’, Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 4 (2012), 94–101.

Dekel, Sharon, Daria Mamon, Zahava Solomon, Olivia Lanman, and Gabriella Dishy, ‘Can Guilt Lead to Psychological Growth Following Trauma Exposure?’, Psychiatry Research, 236 (2016), 196-198.

Erbes, Christopher, Raina Eberly, Thomas Dikel, Erica Johnsen, Irene Harris, and Brian Engdahl, ‘Posttraumatic Growth among American Former Prisoners of War’, Traumatology, 11 (2005), 285–95.

Feder, Adriana, Steven M. Southwick, Raymond R. Goetz, Yanping Wang, Angelique Alonso, Bruce W. Smith, and others, ‘Posttraumatic Growth in Former Vietnam Prisoners of War’, Psychiatry: Interpersonal and Biological Processes, 71 (2008), 359–70.

Ginneken, Esther F. J. C. van, ‘Making Sense of Imprisonment Narratives of Posttraumatic Growth Among Female Prisoners’, International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 60 (2016), 208-227.

Gobodo-Madikizela, Pumla, ‘Remorse, Forgiveness, and Rehumanization: Stories from South Africa’, Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 42 (2002), 7–32.

Hatzfeld, Jean, Machete Season: The Killers in Rwanda Speak, trans. by Linda Coverdale, Reprint edition (New York: Picador USA, 2006).

Hijazi, Alaa M., Jessica A. Keith, and Carol O’Brien, ‘Predictors of Posttraumatic Growth in a Multiwar Sample of U.S. Combat Veterans’, Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 21 (2015), 395–408.

Hobfoll, Stevan E., Brian J. Hall, Daphna Canetti-Nisim, Sandro Galea, Robert J. Johnson, and Patrick A. Palmieri, ‘Refining Our Understanding of Traumatic Growth in the Face of Terrorism: Moving from Meaning Cognitions to Doing What Is Meaningful’, Applied Psychology, 56 (2007), 345–66.

Hron, Madelaine, ‘Gukora and Itsembatsemba: The “Ordinary Killers” in Jean Hatzfeld’s Machete Season’, Research in African Literatures, 42 (2011), 125–46.

Hussain, Dilwar, and Braj Bhushan, ‘Posttraumatic Growth Experiences among Tibetan Refugees: A Qualitative Investigation’, Qualitative Research in Psychology, 10 (2013), 204–16.

Janoff-Bulman, Ronnie, Shattered Assumptions: Towards a New Psychology of Trauma (New York, NY US: Free Press, 1992).

Jayawickreme, Eranda, and Laura E. R. Blackie, ‘Post-Traumatic Growth as Positive Personality Change: Evidence, Controversies and Future Directions: Post-Traumatic Growth’, European Journal of Personality, 28 (2014), 312–31.

Joseph, Stephen, ‘A Person-Centered Perspective on Working with People Who Have Experienced Psychological Trauma and Helping Them Move Forward to Posttraumatic Growth’, Person-Centered & Experiential Psychotherapies, 14 (2015), 178–90.

———, ‘Religiosity and Posttraumatic Growth: A Note Concerning the Problems of Confounding in Their Measurement and the Inclusion of Religiosity within the Definition of Posttraumatic Growth’, Mental Health, Religion & Culture, 14 (2011), 843–45.

Joseph, Stephen, and P. Alex Linley, ‘Growth Following Adversity: Theoretical Perspectives and Implications for Clinical Practice’, Clinical Psychology Review, 26 (2006), 1041–53.

———, ‘Positive Adjustment to Threatening Events: An Organismic Valuing Theory of Growth Through Adversity.’, Review of General Psychology, 9 (2005), 262–80.

Joseph, Stephen, John Maltby, Alex M. Wood, Hannah Stockton, Nigel Hunt, and Stephen Regel, ‘The Psychological Well-Being—Post-Traumatic Changes Questionnaire (PWB-PTCQ): Reliability and Validity’, Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 4 (2012), 420–28.

Kelman, Herbert. C, ‘Reconciliation From a Social-Psychological Perspective’, in The Social Psychology of Intergroup Reconciliation, ed. by Arie Nadler, Thomas Malloy, and Jeffrey Fisher D (New York: Oxford University Press, 2008), pp. 15–32.

Kroo, Adrienn, and Henriett Nagy, ‘Posttraumatic Growth Among Traumatized Somali Refugees in Hungary’, Journal of Loss and Trauma, 16 (2011), 440–58.

Lev-Wiesel, Rachel, and Marianne Amir, ‘Posttraumatic Growth Among Holocaust Child Survivors’, Journal of Loss and Trauma, 8 (2003), 229–37.

Linley, P. Alex, and Stephen Joseph, ‘Positive Change Following Trauma and Adversity: A Review’, Journal of Traumatic Stress, 17 (2004), 11–21.

Litz, Brett T., Nathan Stein, Eileen Delaney, Leslie Lebowitz, William P. Nash, Caroline Silva, and others, ‘Moral Injury and Moral Repair in War Veterans: A Preliminary Model and Intervention Strategy’, Clinical Psychology Review, 29 (2009), 695–706.

Lurie-Beck, Janine Karen, Poppy Liossis, and Kathryn Gow, ‘Relationships between Psychopathological and Demographic Variables and Posttraumatic Growth among Holocaust Survivors’, Traumatology, 14 (2008), 28–39.

MacNair, Rachel M., ‘Causing Trauma as a Form of Trauma’, Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 21 (2015), 313–21.

McAdams, Dan P., ‘The Redemptive Self: Generativity and the Stories Americans Live By’, Research in Human Development, 3 (2006), 81–100.

McGrath, Joanna Collicutt, ‘Post-Traumatic Growth and the Origins of Early Christianity’, Mental Health, Religion & Culture, 9 (2006), 291–306.

McLean, Kate C., and Michael W. Pratt, ‘Life’s Little (and Big) Lessons: Identity Statuses and Meaning-Making in the Turning Point Narratives of Emerging Adults’, Developmental Psychology, 42 (2006), 714–22.

Merecz, Dorota, Malgorzata Waszkowska, and Agata Wezyk, ‘Psychological Consequences of Trauma in MVA Perpetrators – Relationship between Post-Traumatic Growth, PTSD Symptoms and Individual Characteristics’, Transportation Research: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour, 15 (2012), 565–74.

Miller, Christian, ‘A Satisfactory Definition of Post-Traumatic Growth Still Remains Elusive’, European Journal of Personality, 28, (2014), 344–46.

Mitchell, Mary M., M. Shayne Gallaway, Amy M. Millikan, and Michael R. Bell, ‘Combat Exposure, Unit Cohesion, and Demographic Characteristics of Soldiers Reporting Posttraumatic Growth’, Journal of Loss and Trauma, 18 (2013), 383–95.

Nadler, Arie, and Nurit Shnabel, ‘Instrumental and Socioemotional Paths to Intergroup Reconciliation and the Needs-Based Model of Socioemotional Reconciliation’, in The Social Psychology of Intergroup Reconciliation, ed. by Arie Nadler, Thomas Malloy, and Jeffrey Fisher D (New York: Oxford University Press, 2008), pp. 37–56.

O’Donnell, Ian, Prisoners, Solitude, and Time (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014).

Pals, Jennifer L., and Dan P. McAdams, ‘The Transformed Self: A Narrative Understanding of Posttraumatic Growth’, Psychological Inquiry, 15 (2004), 65–69.

Pietrzak, Robert H., Marc B. Goldstein, James C. Malley, Alison J. Rivers, Douglas C. Johnson, Charles A. Morgan III, and others, ‘Posttraumatic Growth in Veterans of Operations Enduring Freedom and Iraqi Freedom’, Journal of Affective Disorders, 126 (2010), 230–35.

Pollard, Claire, and Paul Kennedy, ‘A Longitudinal Analysis of Emotional Impact, Coping Strategies and Post-Traumatic Psychological Growth Following Spinal Cord Injury: A 10-Year Review’, British Journal of Health Psychology, 12 (2007), 347–62.

Powell, Steve, Rita Rosner, Willi Butollo, Richard G. Tedeschi, and Lawrence G. Calhoun, ‘Posttraumatic Growth after War: A Study with Former Refugees and Displaced People in Sarajevo’, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 59 (2003), 71–83.

Rotella, Katie N., Jennifer A. Richeson, and Dan P. McAdams, ‘Groups’ Search for Meaning: Redemption on the Path to Intergroup Reconciliation’, Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 18 (2015), 696–715.

Salo, Jari A., Samir Qouta, and Raija-Leena Punamäki, ‘Adult Attachment, Posttraumatic Growth and Negative Emotions among Former Political Prisoners’, Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, 18 (2005), 361–78.

Salo, Jari, Raija-Leena Punamäki, Samir Qouta, and Eyad El Sarraj, ‘Individual and Group Treatment and Self and Other Representations Predicting Posttraumatic Recovery Among Former Political Prisoners’, Traumatology, 14 (2008), 45–61.

Schaal, Susanne, Roland Weierstall, Jean-Pierre Dusingizemungu, and Thomas Elbert, ‘Mental Health 15 Years after the Killings in Rwanda: Imprisoned Perpetrators of the Genocide against the Tutsi versus a Community Sample of Survivors’, Journal of Traumatic Stress, 25 (2012), 446–53.

Smeulers, Alette., and Lotte. Hoex, ‘Studying the Microdynamics of the Rwandan Genocide’, British Journal of Criminology, 50 (2010), 435–54.

Smeulers, Alette, Perpetrators of International Crimes: Towards a Typology (Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network, 22 January 2014) [accessed 16 February 2016]

Solomon, Zahava, and Rachel Dekel, ‘Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Posttraumatic Growth among Israeli Ex-Pows’, Journal of Traumatic Stress, 20 (2007), 303–12.

Splevins, Katie, Keren Cohen, Jake Bowley, and Stephen Joseph, ‘Theories of Posttraumatic Growth: Cross-Cultural Perspectives’, Journal of Loss and Trauma, 15 (2010), 259–77.

Staub, Ervin, ‘Building a Peaceful Society: Origins, Prevention, and Reconciliation after Genocide and Other Group Violence.’, American Psychologist, 68 (2013), 576–89.

Staub, Ervin, and Johanna Vollhardt, ‘Altruism Born of Suffering: The Roots of Caring and Helping After Victimization and Other Trauma’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 78 (2008), 267–80.

Strauss, Scott, The Order of Genocide: Race, Power, and War in Rwanda. (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2006).

Tedeschi, Richard G., ‘Violence Transformed: Posttraumatic Growth in Survivors and Their Societies’, Aggression and Violent Behavior, 4 (1999), 319–41.

Tedeschi, Richard G., and Lawrence G. Calhoun, ‘Posttraumatic Growth: Conceptual Foundations and Empirical Evidence”’, Psychological Inquiry, 15 (2004), 1–18.

Tedeschi, Richard G., and Richard J. McNally, ‘Can We Facilitate Posttraumatic Growth in Combat Veterans?’, American Psychologist, 66 (2011), 19–24.

Tedeschi, Richard G., Crystal L. Park, and Lawrence G. Calhoun, ‘Posttraumatic Growth: Conceptual Issues’, in Posttraumatic Growth: Positive Changes in the Aftermath of Crisis, ed. by Richard G. Tedeschi, Crystal L. Park, and Lawrence G. Calhoun (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1998), pp. 1–22.

Vanhooren, Siebrecht, Mia Leijssen, and Jessie Dezutter, ‘Posttraumatic Growth in Sex Offenders A Pilot Study With a Mixed-Method Design’, International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 61, (2015), 171-190.

Van Winkle, Elizabeth P., and Martin A. Safer, ‘Killing versus Witnessing in Combat Trauma and Reports of PTSD Symptoms and Domestic Violence’, Journal of Traumatic Stress, 24 (2011), 107–10.

Waller, James E., Becoming Evil: How Ordinary People Commit Genocide and Mass Killing: How Ordinary People Commit Genocide and Mass Murder, 2 edition (New York: Oxford University Press, USA, 2007).

Wang, Yanbo, Hongbiao Wang, Ji Wang, Jing Wu, and Xiaohong Liu, ‘Prevalence and Predictors of Posttraumatic Growth in Accidentally Injured Patients’, Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings, 20 (2012), 3–12.

Williamson, Caroline, ‘Towards a Theory of Collective Posttraumatic Growth in Rwanda: The Pursuit of Agency and Communion.’, Traumatology: An International Journal, 20 (2014), 91–102.

Zorbas, Eugenia, ‘Reconciliation in Post-Genocide Rwanda’, African Journal of Legal Studies, 1 (2004), 29–52.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.21039/jpr.v1i1.39

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2017 Laura E.R. Blackie, Nicki Hitchcott, Stephen Joseph

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

ISSN: 2514-7897